Which state should you pick for your LLC if the main goal is accepting payments through Stripe? We compare Wyoming, Delaware and New Mexico on actual fees, look at what the state has no influence on at all, and walk through the whole path from registration to your first payment.

Step 01Compare Wyoming, Delaware and New Mexico on cost

For an online business with no office in the US, choosing a state is mostly a question of annual costs. Your income tax barely changes either way (more on that in the next step), but the mandatory fees you pay the state can differ several times over.

  • Wyoming. Filing (Articles of Organization) - $100 plus a card processing fee for paying online. Every year you file an Annual Report, starting at $60, due on the first day of the month in which the company was formed.
  • Delaware. Filing (Certificate of Formation) - about $110. Every year there is a flat LLC tax, which according to the Division of Corporations currently stands at $400, due June 1. Paying late costs you a $200 penalty plus 1.5% per month.
  • New Mexico. Filing - $50, with no annual report for LLCs and no annual state fee either.

All three states require a registered agent - a company with an address in the state that receives official mail on your behalf. Its fee is paid separately and often turns out to be your biggest annual expense. Agents charge different prices, so look beyond the first year and check what renewal costs.

A word on anonymity. None of these states requires members' names to appear in the public registry. But that changes nothing for Stripe or your bank: they will still ask who owns the company and request a passport. Anonymity is about the public registry, not about compliance.

ImportantMany sources still quote $300 for Delaware. At the time of writing, the state's official page lists $400. Check corp.delaware.gov before you pay - the amount has changed before.

Step 02Understand what the state doesn't affect

A common mistake is picking a state "with no taxes." Wyoming and New Mexico do have a reputation as business-friendly states, but a non-resident LLC's main obligations are federal. They're the same in every state.

By default, a single-member LLC with a foreign owner is treated as a disregarded entity - it's "transparent" for tax purposes. However, the IRS separately requires these companies to file an annual return: Form 5472 together with a pro forma Form 1120. You have to file it even if you made no sales: owner contributions, withdrawals and payments of company expenses all count as reportable transactions.

According to the IRS, the penalty for a missing or incomplete form is $25,000. If you still haven't filed within 90 days of an IRS notice, another $25,000 is added for every 30 days. You can extend the deadline with Form 7004, but it has to be filed before the original due date.

We cover how to fill out and submit the form in detail in our article "Form 5472 for a Non-Resident LLC". The key takeaway here: your state affects what you pay the state, not your relationship with the IRS.

Step 03Assess sanctions risk if you hold a Russian or Belarusian passport

A Russian or Belarusian citizen can form an LLC - states don't ask about citizenship. The problems start at the bank and payment processor stage. Stripe, Mercury and Wise are American or European companies; they are required to follow sanctions rules, and they vet the owner, not just the company.

Here's what the services' official help pages say at the time of writing:

  • Mercury states in its help center that international transfers are unavailable if the company's or beneficiary's address is in Russia or Belarus. In 2024 the bank also closed accounts en masse for companies with founders from these countries.
  • Wise doesn't open accounts for people with an address in Russia or Belarus. Russian citizens with a verified address in another country may still be able to use the service.
  • Stripe doesn't work with persons in sanctioned jurisdictions, and during verification it asks for the owner's citizenship, address and documents.

What to put in the application: only the truth. Your real residential address, real citizenship and real line of business. Nominee owners and borrowed addresses are a direct violation of the services' terms and a common reason for accounts being frozen with money already in the balance.

The real way to reduce the risk is legal residency and an address in a third country (Georgia, Armenia, Kazakhstan, EU countries), backed by documents: a bank statement, a utility bill, a lease agreement. It doesn't guarantee approval, but without it the odds for a resident of Russia or Belarus are slim.

TipPut together your address documents in advance - in English or with a translation. Banks and Stripe often ask for proof of address no older than 3 months, and a delay here can hold up verification for weeks.

Step 04Form your LLC and get an EIN

From here on, the process is the same in every state.

  1. Choose a registered agent and file your formation document with the state, either through the agent or yourself. This usually takes a few business days.
  2. Prepare an Operating Agreement - the LLC's internal governing document. The state doesn't require it, but banks often ask for it.
  3. Get an EIN - your company's tax ID number. Without an SSN you can't apply online, so Form SS-4 is sent by fax or mail. A fax reply comes back noticeably faster than one by mail.

Without an EIN you can't open a bank account or a Stripe account, so don't put this step off. Step-by-step instructions are in our article "How to Get an EIN for a Non-Resident LLC Without an SSN".

Step 05Open a bank account and pick a state that won't raise eyebrows

Stripe pays out to the company's bank account, so you need the account before connecting the payment processor. US banks almost always ask non-residents for an EIN, formation documents, a passport and proof of address.

There's a catch with the state. Some banks informally prefer Delaware because their compliance teams are used to it. Wyoming and New Mexico LLCs do get accounts too, but you may face more questions about the company's purpose and its ties to the US. Stripe doesn't publicly name a preferred state - what matters more to it is the owner, the website and the business model.

If your top priority is fewer questions from banks and payment processors, Delaware is worth the extra few hundred dollars a year. If your budget is tight and the owner has no "sanctioned" addresses, Wyoming is a sensible compromise. New Mexico is the cheapest of all, but more often triggers follow-up questions.

For a comparison of Mercury, Relay and other options, see our article "US Bank Account for a Non-Resident LLC".

Step 06Set up Stripe and accept your first payment

Sign up at stripe.com, select United States as your country and LLC as your business type. Stripe will then ask for your EIN, business address, website, product description and representative details.

According to Stripe's help center, if the representative has no SSN or ITIN, they need to provide their tax ID from their country of residence and confirm they are not a US tax resident. Don't try to "find" an SSN or enter someone else's details - it will end in a ban.

Before you submit the application, get your website ready: pages with contacts, shipping, returns and a privacy policy, plus real prices and product descriptions. An empty site or a mismatch between your business description and your storefront is a frequent reason for rejection. Once approved, make a test payment, and keep your volume steady for the first few weeks, without sudden spikes.

If you'd rather not deal with the application and the risks yourself, you can hand the setup over to people who do it regularly. The MakeItEarn team helps with Stripe accounts: we'll suggest the structure that fits your situation and help you get your website ready for review.

SummaryChecklist before you register

  • Calculate your costs 2-3 years ahead: state fee plus registered agent. Delaware is currently $400 a year, Wyoming from $60, New Mexico has no annual fee.
  • Remember that Form 5472 and a pro forma 1120 are required in any state, even with no sales.
  • If you hold a Russian or Belarusian passport, secure proof of a legal address in a third country in advance. Without it, the bank and Stripe will most likely turn you down.
  • Get your EIN right after registration - nothing opens without it.
  • Open a bank account before applying to Stripe, and get your website ready for review.
  • Only provide real information in your applications.

If you want fewer questions from banks, go with Delaware. If you want it cheaper and don't mind follow-up questions, go with Wyoming. Everything else doesn't depend on the state.

Message us on TelegramWe'll help you connect Stripe to your LLC
Enjoyed the article? Share it